Grading Prep
Don't waste money submitting cards that won't make the cut. We'll tell you exactly which ones are worth it — and handle everything from there.
Choose Your Service
All services available by mail or in person at events. Screening results are emailed within 2–3 business days, along with a recommended grading company. Card Prep timelines depend on the grading company.
- Pass or fail verdict on each card
- Evaluated against PSA, CGC, and Beckett standards
- Best for large lots where you just need to cull the obvious misses
- Everything in Standard Screen
- Cards that fail get written notes and photos documenting exactly what's wrong and where
- Best for high-value cards where details matter
- Microfiber dust-off — no substances or alterations to the card
- Placed in a penny sleeve and card saver
- Submitted through the grading company that makes the most sense for the card — PSA, CGC, or Beckett
Not included in the $5: grading submission fees (set by PSA, CGC, or Beckett based on service tier) and shipping insurance (available at your option).
Stack Your Services
Pair Detailed Screen + Card Prep for the complete service — thorough evaluation with notes on any failing cards, plus physical prep and submission to the right grading company for each card. You get your card back once it comes in from grading. Check both options when building your list below.
Error Cards Welcome
Miscuts, misprints, wrong backs — all welcome. We send error cards to CGC for their detailed error labeling and handle the submission on your behalf.
How It Works
Submit Your List
Use the form below to search each card, choose your service level, and send us your request.
We Review & Approve
We review every request before you ship anything. We want to give each card the attention it deserves — capacity can fill up, so we confirm availability first.
Send Us Your Cards
Once approved, mail your cards in or hand them off at an event. We confirm receipt and send payment instructions before any work begins.
We Evaluate
Each card is reviewed against PSA, CGC, and Beckett standards within 2–3 business days. Standard Screen returns a pass/fail verdict. Detailed Screen adds written notes and photos for every card that fails.
Results by Email
Screening results are sent by email. Cards not being submitted for grading can ship back right away or be held and returned together with your graded cards — your choice.
Graded Cards Come Back
For Card Prep orders, we choose the right grading company for each card (PSA, CGC, or Beckett) and handle the submission. Submission fees and optional insurance are billed separately. Once the graded cards come in, we ship everything back to you together.
Submit Your Cards
Search each card, pick your service, and send us your list. We'll confirm and follow up within 2–3 business days.
Your Cards
Your Order
Turnarounds are PSA estimates and set by the grading company — they can shift with volume. We pass along what they publish but can't guarantee exact delivery times. Need different turnarounds for different cards? Send two separate requests through this form — you can bundle them in one package as long as each printout stays with its own cards.
Questions before you submit? Reach out and we'll walk you through it.
Already submitted? Track your order →